The gridiron game has a penalty for illegal holding. We need one for hoarding.
The biggest surprise up in the Swiss Alps this week at the Davos World Economic Forum? Reporters who cover this annual global bacchanal of billionaires are marveling at the warm and friendly reception that has greeted Donald Trump. The world’s deepest pockets have wined and dined with the U.S. president, laughed at his quips, and profusely fed his ego.
“Africa,” the billionaire South African mining mogul Patrice Motsepe told the president, “loves you.”
And Trump loves the Davos deep pockets back, at one point hailing the big-time corporate CEOs gathered around him as “the greatest businessmen in the world.”
Quite a difference from Trump’s first Davos visit. In 2018, he encountered a distinctly uneasy assemblage of the excessively rich. Would this “America First” president set off an international trade war? Would he trash their elite status? Would he screw up the good thing they had going? The corporate execs and political heavyweights gathered at Davos two years ago didn’t quite know what to expect.
Today, two years later, that discomfort has disappeared. “Davos Man” likes what Donald Trump has delivered. Klaus Schwab, the founder of the Davos World Economic Forum, made all that clear when he took the stage with the president on the confab’s 50th opening day. Schwab lauded Trump “for injecting optimism” into the global political and economic discourse.
“We have many problems in the world,” pronounced the grand old man of Davos, “but we need dreams.”
In his 30-minute Davos keynote address, the president would do more crowing than dreaming. His administration, he declared, had created a “roaring geyser of opportunity.” The United States is enjoying “an economic boom — the likes of which the world has never seen before.” Trump even declared victory over inequality.
“For the first time in decades, we are no longer simply concentrating wealth in the hands of a few,” he announced. “We’re concentrating and creating the most inclusive economy ever to exist.”
Fact-checkers would almost immediately start debunking the President’s various claims, but the Davos crowd didn’t particularly seem to mind the misinformation. Trump, they’ve concluded, has done good.
“There are lot of masters of the universe who think he may not be their cup of tea, but he’s been a godsend,” explained Ian Bremmer, a mover and shaker behind the Eurasia Group business consultancy.
A godsend who’s cut taxes and regulations and made making money ever easier for people who already have plenty of it. And that nastiness about trade wars? Trump’s offensive against “free trade,” notes This Week’s Jeff Spross, has boiled down to “essentially a showman’s wrestling match — a slugfest devoid of policy substance, far too shallow to have any concrete chance of rebalancing the money flows and scales of power” that align against working people.
The Davos annual get-together — with its $10,000 hotel rooms and $43 hotdogs — has always served as a reminder of the vast and growing divide that separates the world’s richest and most powerful from the rest of us. But this year’s gathering seems to be rubbing that reminder in.
Davos applauds while Donald Trump celebrates a “roaring geyser of opportunity.” But in the United States and most of the rest of the world, few people are feeling any spray from a “roaring geyser.” How few? One answer — from the global research firm Edelman Intelligence — came just before this year’s Davos celebration opened.
Edelman last fall surveyed over 34,000 respondents across the world and found a “growing sense of inequity.” In developed nations, details a new Edelman report, less than a third of families see themselves as better off five years from now. Over three-quarters see elites “getting richer while regular people struggle to pay their bills.”
The super rich who fly their private jets into Davos every year and most of the rest of humanity simply live in two extraordinarily different economic universes, the one a world of wealth, the other a world of work. In the world of work, people depend on their sweat and skills to put food on the table and roofs over their heads. If they want to afford more and better, they put in extra hours. They take a second job.
In the world of wealth, the rich don’t have to work ever harder to see their net worth spike. They let their assets do the heavy lifting. Sitting on those assets — their stocks, bonds, real estate, and businesses — brings dividends, interest, rent, and profits. Selling those assets brings capital gains income.
A truly sweet deal. A perpetual wealth-generation machine that swings into motion, as Seagrams heir Edgar Bronfman once related, for anyone who can afford to enter the world of wealth.
“To turn $100 into $110 is work,” observed Bronfman. “To turn $100 million into $110 million is inevitable.”
But added millions only become dependably inevitable when government helpfully greases the skids for wealth’s unfettered accumulation. And governments do that all the time, by everything from taxing the rich at rates that leave them barely inconvenienced to undermining worker rights to bargain collectively for a fair share of the wealth they create.
Donald Trump has done plenty of that greasing — and made himself indispensable to the Davos crowd in the process. The global mega rich once saw Trump as a “great disaster,” and now, says Niall Ferguson of Stanford University’s conservative Hoover Institution, “they’re all a great deal richer than they were back then.” These rich don’t want the Trump boom to end. As Ferguson puts it: “The dirty little secret of Davos 2020 is they all need him to get re-elected.”
Not all the rich, of course, feel that way, and one group of more egalitarian-minded people of means — the U.S.-based Patriotic Millionaires — took their message to Davos Wednesday. In an open letter entitled “Millionaires Against Pitchforks,” the group decried the “epidemic” of tax evasion by the world’s wealthiest and called extreme wealth “a sign of a failing economic system.”
“For that reason,” the Patriotic Millionaires open letter to Davos 2020-goers continued, “we urge you to step forward now — before it’s too late — to demand higher and fairer taxes on millionaires and billionaires within your own countries.”
Added the letter’s 121 signers, a cohort that included a former Unilever CEO and Disney heiress Abigail Disney: “We make this request as members of the most privileged class of human beings ever to walk the Earth.”
Sam Pizzigati co-edits Inequality.org. His recent books include The Case for a Maximum Wage and The Rich Don’t Always Win: The Forgotten Triumph over Plutocracy that Created the American Middle Class, 1900-1970. Follow him at @Too_Much_Online.