A project of the
Institute for Policy Studies

Women’s Wages Can No Longer Rescue the American Family

For the past forty years American men’s incomes have stagnated.  The US economy has doubled in real per capita terms since 1973, but the median male wage income has fallen by 7.5%.  Wages for young men age 25-34 have fallen even further, by 18.7%.  While marriage once meant that a couple could survive on one income, today two incomes are essential for all but the super-rich.  Women have come to the rescue of the American family.

Women’s incomes have risen a whopping 73.7% since 1973 as the percentage of women with children who work has risen from 47% to 72%.  Even among women who work full-time, the median wage income has risen from $28,485 in 1973 to $35,574 in 2009 (adjusted for inflation).  The combination of more women going to work and working women earning more than they used to has kept the American family afloat.  As a result of women’s work, US median family income has risen modestly (up 15.6%) instead of declining over the past 40 years.

The problem is that this trick won’t work in the future.  Women’s wages are no longer rising, and they’re no longer catching up with men’s.  In fact, the data suggest they never did catch up.  Among women working in occupations that have always been female-dominated, wages have fallen 4.5% since 1973 — and contrary to popular perceptions, the number of young women choosing careers in historically female-dominated professions is increasing, not decreasing.

The great female cash infusion is now over.

What’s more, women’s labor force participation maxed out in 2000 and hasn’t budged since.  Female labor force participation in the United States is already much higher than in Europe and the rest of the developed world, a full seven percentage points higher than in the European Union.  There is little likelihood that American women will be able to continue to bail out the American family by working more.

The great female cash infusion is now over.  What next then for the American family?  It’s hard to say.  Men’s wages are falling.  Women’s wages have stopped rising.  Everyone who is likely to work is already working — or looking for work.  Unless children start going back to work in the coalmines, things look bad for the American family.  The only way out is to raise wages for everyone, men as well as women.  The alternative is a decline even worse than we’ve experienced so far.

Neither Presidential candidate is talking about measures to raise wages.  Tax cuts, yes.  Wage increases, no.  There are ways to raise wages.  The government can raise the minimum wage with a simple act of Congress.  Governments can stop trying to break unions and instead promote unionization.  Government can lead by example, raising wages for federal workers at a pace higher than inflation.  It can be done.

It can be done, and it should be done.  How long can we accept a 1973 wage structure?  Isn’t forty years more than enough?  The economy has doubled.  Wages should have doubled — or more.  The fact that they haven’t is an indictment of our governments and our leaders.  You can’t blame private companies for not raising wages.  You can blame the people who are supposed to work for us: our governments.

  • Lost because of the law

    I wonder if male wages would be as they are now if so many women didn’t enter the workforce? I doubt it. Simple matter of supply and demand. Everyone has fallen for the BS of equality in the workplace. It is now that perhaps people will wake up to the fact that all that has truly happened is the government gained twice the tax income. While at the same time causing problems for families, and the family unit itself. I hope that someday history will be ABLE to look back and say what were they thinking? There was a time when people complimented each other rather than today’s constant fight over who gets more. Pass another law to FORCE change down everyone’s throat.

    • DHFabian

      No, that’s a simplistic and long-disproved argument, based on an era that no longer exists. The original argument for higher wages for men was that men were providers for families, with women’s wages merely being a second source of income. Times have changed. Our economic deterioration is complex, and the result of years of remarkably short-sighted policies.

      If we throw away the “politically acceptable” rhetoric and look at what the US actually did, the issue becomes clear. The US shipped out a huge number of jobs since the 1980s, ended actual welfare in the 1990s.This created a huge surplus of job-ready people who are absolutely desperate for any job at any wage (there is nothing to fall back on). This very fact has put all the power into the hands of employers/corporations. We don’t dare fight back because we can’t risk losing our jobs.

  • williamedward

    Women deserve less wages than men, right Lost?

Read previous post:
America Is Even More Unequal than It Seems

Differences in the ways people live are only partly determined by income. They're also determined by the levels of government...